|
|

While Gil Portes's
Gatas Sa Dibdib Ng Kaaway (At The Breast Of The Enemy) succeeds as an
economically-made low budget feature, the drama is never milked (sic) out
of the otherwise well-written story. Noel Vera feels undernourished.
|
|
THE
ASIAN VALUES DVD REVIEW
|
It's part of
Gil Portes's genius as a producer that he was able to take the sets
and costumes he used while making Markova: Comfort Gay to shoot
another film at the same time - two movies, almost for the price
of one.
Gatas Sa
Dibdib Ng Kaaway (At The Breast Of The Enemy), like Markova,
is set during the Japanese occupation of the Philippines, in World
War II. It's the story of a young woman (Mylene Dizon), whose husband
(Jomari Yllana), is arrested by the soldiers of a Japanese garrison,
on the suspicion that he is a guerilla. Dizon pleads her case to
the garrison's commander (Kenji Motoki), who sympathizes and lets
Yllana go; when the commander's wife dies and leaves their son motherless,
Dizon (who is nursing), is hired to feed the baby from her own breast.
| |
 |
It's a lovely
story (by Jose Dalisay Jr. and Portes) and the script (by Dalisay)
develops it quite nicely. Unfortunately, a lovely script is only
half the picture. The film feels like a rough-cut rather than the
finished product - the telling is a touch too slow, scenes go on
a touch too long, and there are moments when you can actually see
the actors waiting for their cues.
I've sat through my share of slow movies - the works of Theo Angolopoulos
and Andrei Tarkovsky come to mind - and even dozed through some
of them, but rarely have I ever felt annoyed by the less-than-lively
pace, mainly because I felt they knew what they were doing. Such
films draw us out; make us want to wait and see what happens; bring
us to a kind of suspended hypnotized state with their thrillingly
mysterious reserve. A film that is slow because it's trying to approximate
that kind of storytelling - and not succeeding very well - can be
irritating in the extreme.
As for the
performances - Mylene Dizon acquits herself well enough (it's her
picture, after all), and shows her (reputed) surgically enhanced
breasts with winning ease, but her menfolk are woefully inadequate.
Motoki is tall and handsome and wooden (I've seen livelier anime
on Saturday morning television); Yllana I've followed through many
films under many directors, and I've yet to see his mouth move once
(I suspect the dialogue comes out through speakers hidden behind
his ears).
 |
|
Then there
are the many missed opportunities... like when Yllana is beaten
by the Japanese and all Dizon has to offer is her milk, and Motoki
catches them at it together - that should have been a charged moment,
full of surprise and fear and unexpected eroticism; instead, Dizon
gives a short apology and the matter is dropped. Later, when Motoki
enters the living room and finds Dizon giving her breast to his
child, there should have been more drama, more feeling to the scene,
but no - Dizon casually explains that the child wanted milk, so
she supplied him (it's as if her nipples were an ATM machine, ready
to service anyone in need with functional efficiency).
Perhaps the
film's most courageous artistic choice - and most damning failure
- is in allowing itself similarities to the classic of the genre,
Mario O'Hara's Tatlong Taong Walang Diyos (Three Years Without
God). The parallels are obvious: both are set during the Occupation,
both involve a woman forced to decide between her Filipino and Japanese
lover.
But where Gatas's Japanese officer is a milky-veined gentleman,
Tatlong's is a rapist, with demons in his past; where Dizon
is adequate as a loving (and rather passive) mother and housewife,
Tatlong's Nora Aunor breathes fire into her role as a woman
torn in two. After watching Gatas, I can safely say
that the heights and depths, the glories and terrors of the human
heart were not plumbed; I couldn't say the same after watching
Tatlong Taong Walang Diyos.
Note:
Businessworld,
January 12, 2001.
The article also appears in Noel Vera's Critic After Dark: A Review
Of Philippine Cinema (BigO Books).
Click here to order.
|


For more... email singbigo@singnet.com.sg
with the message, "Put me on your mailing list."
|
|
Click
here for other Asian Values DVD Reviews:
In
The Navel Of The Sea
The Girlie Bar
Dyesebel
Starlets For Sale
Milagros
The Amorous Lotus Pan
Curacha
Big Bad Sis
Yesterday Children
The Sugar Daddies
Tinimbang Judged Today
Bruce Lee And I
Lady Chatterley's Lubbe
The Boxer's Omen
The Foxy Ladies
Sidhi
Corpse Mania
Pale
Passion
Your
Wife, My Wife
Raw Passions
Pussy
Hairs
Pale Passion
Pila
Balde
Sinful Adulteress
Flower
Of Manila
Sinful Confession
The Most Beautiful Creature On The Face Of The Earth
Sexy
Playgirls
Toro
(Live Show)
Sexy
Career Girls
Woman
Of Mud
That's
Adultery
Prosti
Adultery,
Chinese Style
Tatlo
Women Of Desire
Naked Under The Moon
Hex
Virgin
People
Love
Swindler
Tatarin
Girl
With The Long Hair
Scorpio
Nights
Sex
For Sale
Tatsulok
36
Secrets Of Courtship
Biyaheng
Langit
Sexy Girls Of Denmark
Laman
Golden
Lotus: Love And Desire
Tuhog (Larger Than Life)
Dreams
Of Eroticism
Legends
Of Lust
Amorous
Woman Of Tang Dynasty
Hong
Kong Hong Kong
Kiss Of Death
Crazy Sex
Forbidden Tales Of Two Cities
The Call Girls |